How Can We Help?
Peer Review Process for JournalsPeer Review Process for Journals
Peer review in Digital Commons can be single-blind or double-blind, depending on how you'd like Consulting Services to set up your publication. Double-blind review is more often used for journals. This article covers topics most relevant to journals, including details about double-blind review and managing author revisions. The steps for managing reviewers, review requests, reports, and re-review are the same for all publication structures and are described in Peer Review Tools.
Single-Blind vs. Double-Blind Peer Review
With both types, authors do not see reviewers’ names. The key difference is whether reviewers can see authors’ names.
| In single-blind peer review | Reviewers can see authors’ names throughout the review process. |
|---|---|
| In double-blind peer review |
Reviewers cannot see authors’ names during the review process. Authors’ names are hidden from metadata and PDF cover pages shown to reviewers. To help protect anonymity in the manuscript itself, the submission form overview page includes a note to authors not to include their name in their full-text document. In addition, author revisions are automatically hidden so editors can confirm anonymity before sharing with reviewers. After an editorial decision of "Accept Submission" or "Accept Submission with minor revisions" on a manuscript, the authors’ names reappear on the cover page for publication. To leave the paper open for another round of peer review, register a decision of “Major revisions required for acceptance.” This allows re-review and maintains double-blind status. |
Peer Review Workflow for Journals
Peer review for a journal manuscript follows these steps. Each step links to detailed instructions in Peer Review Tools.
- On the Submission Details page, select Reviewers in the left sidebar. This link appears only if the journal’s Configuration page has a value in Maximum number of reviewers per article. See Access Peer Review Tools.
- Compile a list of suggested reviewers. Suggested reviewers are not notified until you send a formal request. See Suggest Reviewers.
- Send review requests and, if necessary, adjust the maximum number of reviewers. See Send Review Requests and Setting the Number of Reviewers per Manuscript.
- Reviewers commit to the review and submit reports. You can commit or submit on a reviewer’s behalf. See Reviewers Commit to Review and How Reviews Are Submitted.
- Remind, replace, or give up on reviewers who are late. See Following up with delinquent reviewers.
- Review submitted reports. By default, reports are shared with authors after you register an editorial decision, and you can hide individual reports. See Monitoring the Review Process and Sharing Reviews with Authors.
Managing Author Revisions During the Review Process
Authors may submit revisions anytime prior to publication, causing multiple versions of a manuscript to be available during peer review. Editors can choose which version of a manuscript is available to reviewers and becomes slated for publication. Alternatively, editors can lock a manuscript to prevent revisions. Both options are described below.
To view a revision and select the current version of a manuscript:
- Navigate to the Submission Details page. (The link in notification emails for new revisions also opens the Submission Details page.)
- Select View revisions in the left sidebar.
- The Revision History table displays all versions of the full-text and cover letter documents submitted to date, as well as their converted PDF counterparts.
- To select a version for peer review and publication, select the radio button next to the version and select Save changes.
If the journal uses double-blind peer review, Hide checkboxes also appear next to the PDF versions so editors can hide a version that reveals author identity.

Lock a manuscript to prevent author revisions:
Prior to publication, editors can lock a manuscript to prevent unauthorized revisions by authors. To lock a manuscript, select “Yes” from the Locked by Editor drop-down on the Submission Details page. Authors can still view locked manuscripts in process but cannot edit them. Editors can revise locked, unpublished manuscripts. Editors can also revise published submissions, which authors can no longer revise, even when the submission is unlocked.
Re-Review After Revisions
When editors register a decision of “Major revisions required for acceptance,” the manuscript can be sent out for a second round of peer review. Typically the original reviewers are asked again, but editors can select any reviewer from the Master List of Reviewers. For the steps, see Re-Review in Peer Review Tools.
If the journal uses double-blind peer review, check the revised version for identifying information before sending it out. Use the Hide checkboxes on the View Revisions page if needed.
Digital Commons Help Center