How Can We Help?
Peer Review ToolsPeer Review Tools
Peer review is available in all Digital Commons publication structures, except image galleries. You can take advantage of either single-blind or double-blind peer review using robust tools for managing reviewer lists, reviews, and turnaround time.
This guide includes general instructions applicable to all publication structures. For journal-specific instructions and information about double-blind peer review, which is most often used with journals, see Peer Review Process for Journals.
Configure Peer Review
Publications such as series and journals offer the following peer review settings on the Configuration page, under the Review heading. Other options are available by contacting Consulting Services.
- Maximum number of reviewers per article: A number is required here to display the Reviewers link in the Submission Details sidebar (within Manage Submissions). The system will allow this number of reviewers to commit to review requests. Administrators may override this selection for an individual submission using the options provided on the Reviewers page of any submission.
- Number of days to submit a review: The system will prompt reviewers to complete their reviews in the number of days indicated. Administrators may override this selection using the options provided on the Reviewers page of any submission.
Access Peer Review Tools
To begin the review process for a submission, navigate to the Submission Details page by clicking the submission's title on the Manage Submissions page. Click Reviewers in the left-hand sidebar of Submission Details.

You can use the Reviewers link to access all peer review functions for a manuscript. This link only appears if a value is present in Maximum number of reviewers per article on the publication Configuration page.
Suggest Reviewers
On the Reviewers page, you will first compile a list of suggested reviewers for the manuscript. Suggested reviewers do not receive a notification unless the administrator sends a formal request for a review.
There are three options for suggesting reviewers:
- Enter new reviewer: Enter the full name and email address of the person. The affiliation field is optional.
- From Master List of Reviewers: These are all the people who have reviewed for the publication in the past, as well as any new reviewers designated to appear on this list. This list can be searched and sorted to locate a particular reviewer.
- From Author List: Displays all authors who have submitted to the publication. By default, authors are added to the Master List of Reviewers. If you would prefer not to include authors in this list, please contact Consulting Services.
Reviewers page, with one reviewer in the “suggested” status:

Checking Reviewer History
You may check on a reviewer’s history with the publication by clicking the history link for each suggested reviewer. (Use the review history link in the Status column if you wish to see a reviewer’s activity for that submission only.)
Click the Show all button to view the full Master List of Reviewers. You can also return to the list at any time by clicking Reviewer list in the Manage Submissions sidebar.

Each row in the reviewers list includes last name, first name, institution, and a Subject area notes text field where administrators and editors can enter optional notes about the reviewer (reviewers do not see these). The remaining columns show:
- the number of outstanding requests for the reviewer
- the number of manuscripts the reviewer is currently assigned to
- whether the reviewer has completed any reviews in the past 45 days
- the number of reviews the reviewer has completed in the past 12 months
- the average time the reviewer takes to complete a review
- whether the reviewer is an author in the publication
A Remove checkbox also appears on the left. Check one or more rows to remove those individuals from the list of reviewers, then click Save changes.
Setting the Number of Reviewers per Manuscript
While administrators can suggest and request an unlimited number of reviewers per manuscript, a maximum number of committed reviewers can also be set. This ensures that no more reviewers than necessary can accept review requests. It also keeps the status messages sent to administrators accurate about how many additional reviews are required. When the maximum number of reviewers have committed, reviewers who have not responded to the request will be notified automatically that the publication no longer requires their review.
Administrators can modify the maximum number of reviewers for all manuscripts or for individual manuscripts.
- To adjust the number of reviewers for all manuscripts, navigate to the Configuration page for the publication and change the number in the Maximum number of reviewers per article field.
- To adjust the number of maximum reviewers for a specific manuscript, use the drop-down menu on the Reviewers page above the Reviewers table. Select the number of reviewers and click Update.
Send Review Requests
After building a list of suggested reviewers, administrators can request reviews from some or all of them.
To send a review request:
- Navigate to the manuscript’s Reviewers page.
- Click the request link that appears under Options for the suggested reviewer.
- Next, you can edit the request email message before sending. By default, the email includes the response deadline, the review due date, and a link where the reviewer accepts or declines the request. The text of the email can be modified. You can also adjust the review due date for this particular reviewer and add attachments, if needed.
- Click Send.
The details shown for that reviewer on the Reviewers page will change to show:
- The status and date of the review request.
- New options available for the reviewer now that the request has been sent.

Options column:
The Options column will change depending on reviewers’ individual status. As a reviewer's status changes (for example, from “requested” to “committed”), certain commands will disappear and new ones will appear.
The commands available at each status are:
- suggested: request; delete
- requested: re-request; withdraw request; commit for reviewer; decline for reviewer
- committed: upload report for reviewer; remind; revise due date; give up
- LATE: Same options as committed.
In addition, you can view the reviewer's email address and initiate an email message by selecting their name in the Reviewer column.
Reviewers Commit to Review
After a review request is sent, the reviewer can click the link provided in the request email to log in and view additional details about the submission. They can click I will review it to commit to review the submission or I will not review it to decline. Administrators will be notified of the decision.
Pictured below is the accept/decline screen that reviewers see, with the PDF visible prior to agreeing. This can be configured by Consulting Services if you'd prefer that reviewers view the PDF only after agreeing.

The reviewer can also access the above page by clicking the submission's title on their My Account page.
Once reviewers commit, they will receive automatic reminders at designated intervals while their reviews are still outstanding. The frequency of these reminders is configurable.
Administrators and editors can commit on behalf of the reviewer by clicking the commit for reviewer link in the Options column for that reviewer.
How Reviews Are Submitted
Once the reviewer has committed to the review, a Submit review link will appear in the reviewer's left sidebar. That link provides access to the report upload form, which is described in detail below.
Reviewer’s view of a submission after committing to review:

Elements of the report upload form:
- Report: Reviews may be submitted as PDF files, MS Word/RTF documents, or plain text pasted into the provided text box. If an MS Word/RTF file is uploaded, it will be converted to a PDF. This automatic conversion removes the reviewer’s identity from the document Properties of any file. It is up to the reviewer and assigned administrator to verify that the reviewer’s identity is not included within the report. The assigned editor/administrator can hide the report if the reviewer mistakenly includes identifying information.
-
Recommendation: The reviewer must choose between three options, all of which are merely suggestions for the editorial decision:
- Encourage major revisions as described in my report.
- Accept this article with minor (or no) revisions as described in my report.
- Reject this article without an option to resubmit.
- Cover Letter (optional): Only visible to administrators. Never shared with authors.
- Attachments (optional): PDF and MS Word/RTF formats are recommended. However, any file type can be attached. The reviewer and assigned administrator should verify that the reviewer’s identity is not revealed in any attachment, as they will become available to the author(s) once an editorial decision is registered.
Once a referee report is submitted, the manuscript’s Last Event will change to “Review completed.” Assigned editors/administrators receive automatic email notification when referee reports are uploaded. Administrators also receive automatic email notification if additional reviewers are needed for a manuscript.
Administrators and editors can submit a review on behalf of the reviewer (e.g., if they email it instead) by clicking the upload report for reviewer link in the Options column for that reviewer. If the publication is set up to show reports to authors after an editorial decision is registered, a report uploaded by an administrator will appear to authors as if the reviewer submitted it.
Following up with delinquent reviewers
The system will notify administrators and reviewers when a review is late or if a potential reviewer hasn’t responded to a request.
Administrators have the following options concerning delinquent reviewers:
- Suggest a new reviewer: Choose a new reviewer from the Master List of Reviewers or author list.
- Remind reviewer: If the due date is approaching or has passed, use remind in the Options column for the reviewer to send a reminder.
- Revise report due date: Choose the revise due date option to specify a new report deadline.
- Give up on a reviewer: Choose the give up option to indicate that a review is no longer expected from the reviewer. The system will notify the reviewer and cease reminding them of the overdue report.
Monitoring the Review Process
Once completed, reviews will appear in a Submitted Reviews table on the Reviewers page. To view a reviewer’s recommended decision and report, click the view link in the Options column for that report.

Sharing Reviews with Authors
By default, referee reports are made available to authors once an editorial decision is made. This option can be disabled by contacting Consulting Services.
Individual reports can be hidden from authors, even after a decision is registered, by choosing the Hide option next to the report on the Reviewers page (shown in the Submitted Reviews screenshot above).
A referee report from an author’s perspective, with the report link shown as Text (will show PDF instead if the reviewer uploaded a PDF):

Re-Review
When administrators register a decision of “Major revisions required for acceptance” for a manuscript, it can be sent out for a second round of peer review, or re-review. Typically, the original reviewers are called upon, but administrators may select any reviewer(s) from the Master List of Reviewers.
When an author submits a revised manuscript, you can choose which version reviewers see and lock the manuscript to prevent further revisions. See Managing Author Revisions During the Review Process.
To send a manuscript out for re-review:
- Navigate to the Submission Details page and click Reviewers in the left-hand sidebar.
- Click the request rereview link beside the reviewers you want to re-review the manuscript. (The link will appear for a reviewer on the Reviewers page as soon as they have submitted the initial review report.)
- Modify the re-review request letter if desired and click Send.
The re-review request letter states that the administrator assumes the reviewer will complete the review unless the reviewer replies otherwise. After a re-review request is sent, the reviewer’s status on the Reviewers page will change to “committed,” and list the due date of the re-review report.
Completed re-review reports will appear in the same Submitted Reviews table on the Reviewers page that contains the manuscript’s first-round reports. Each report is listed individually.

If an editorial decision has already been registered on a manuscript, the system will hide re-review reports submitted by reviewers. Reports will not be made available to authors until the assigned editor/administrator manually unhides the reports on the Reviewers page or registers a new decision (in the screenshot above, the administrator has not yet unhidden the re-review report).
Digital Commons Help Center